Modere, a global multi-level marketing (MLM) company recognized for its “clean-label” health, wellness, and personal care products, abruptly announced its closure on April 11, 2025, ending a 23-year run in the direct selling industry.¹ The announcement, posted on the company’s website which subsequently shut down, confirmed an immediate cessation of operations, offering no detailed explanation for the decision.¹ This sudden move sent shockwaves through its extensive network, leaving potentially millions of customers and thousands of independent distributors across the globe—including in the United States, Canada, Europe, Australia, and Asia—in a state of confusion and uncertainty.¹ The immediacy and opacity surrounding the closure deviate significantly from typical corporate wind-down procedures, which usually involve phased timelines and clearer communication, suggesting the shutdown may have been precipitated by an acute, undisclosed crisis rather than a planned strategic exit.²

The Announcement: A Sudden End to a 23-Year Run

On April 11, 2025, visitors to Modere’s corporate website were met with a stark announcement signaling the end of the company’s operations.² The official statement, described by industry observers as heartfelt, expressed gratitude to the company’s community but provided little concrete information.⁶ “After 23 wonderful years of serving our cherished community, we’ve made the difficult decision to close our doors,” the statement read.¹ It continued, “We’re incredibly grateful for your support, trust, and loyalty over the years. Whether you’ve been with us from the beginning or just discovered us recently, thank you for being a part of our story. From all of us at Modere — thank you. It’s been an honor”.⁷

The closure affects a significant global footprint. Modere operated across numerous international markets, including the United States, Canada, Europe, Australia, New Zealand, Japan, and India.⁵ Reports on the size of its customer base vary, with some sources citing over one million loyal customers worldwide ⁸, while others mention a figure exceeding three million global customers.¹

However, the warmth conveyed in the official farewell message stood in stark contrast to the immediate reality faced by many stakeholders. Reports quickly surfaced of customer frustration over pending orders and unresolved refund issues, coupled with complaints about poor communication.⁸ Distributors, known within Modere as Social Marketers, reported receiving no advance warning, raising concerns about outstanding commission payments, and encountering abrupt changes to their online business portals.⁸ One customer even reported receiving an email indicating that operations were ceasing “effective immediately” and that their funds were “frozen”.¹ This disconnect between the corporate messaging of gratitude and the seemingly chaotic operational reality on the ground suggests a potential breakdown in planning or resources allocated to manage the wind-down process effectively, undermining the intended sentiment of the farewell statement.

Beneath the Surface: Unraveling the Reasons for Closure

While Modere’s official announcement expressed gratitude, it conspicuously omitted any specific reasons for the abrupt shutdown.¹ This lack of transparency fueled widespread speculation across social media and industry forums, with theories ranging from financial distress to regulatory entanglements.⁵

Sources reportedly close to the company, however, have pointed to a combination of factors contributing to the decision.¹ Financial challenges and significant pressure on the business are consistently cited as primary drivers.¹ Alongside financial strain, shifts in consumer behavior and broader market dynamics are also implicated.¹

The post-pandemic economic landscape has proven difficult for many direct-selling brands, and Modere appears to be among those significantly impacted.¹ Increased competition posed a further challenge, with Modere facing pressure from large e-commerce platforms as well as newer, potentially more agile wellness startups offering competitive pricing and product innovation.¹

Regulatory pressures and the associated compliance costs have also been mentioned as contributing factors.¹ This aligns with documented instances of regulatory scrutiny faced by Modere in the period leading up to its closure. In 2023 and 2024, following complaints filed by the consumer advocacy group Truth in Advertising (TINA.org), the Direct Selling Self-Regulatory Council (DSSRC) issued a case decision finding that Modere and its distributors used atypical income claims and unsubstantiated health claims, recommending modifications or discontinuation.¹⁴ Such regulatory actions can impose significant operational burdens and costs, potentially restricting marketing tactics crucial for MLM growth.

The convergence of these factors—external market pressures, intense competition, internal financial difficulties, and mounting regulatory scrutiny—suggests that Modere’s collapse was likely not due to a single catastrophic event but rather a culmination of systemic industry challenges intersecting with company-specific vulnerabilities. The inability to navigate this complex environment effectively appears to have led to the company’s ultimate demise.

Ownership and Internal Pressures: Z Capital, Lawsuits, and Leadership

Modere operated as a portfolio company of Z Capital Partners, L.L.C., the private equity arm of Z Capital Group (“ZCG”).⁹ Z Capital’s involvement dates back to its predecessor company, Neways Enterprises, where it became the majority controlling shareholder in 2013.²⁰ At the time of Modere’s acquisition of Jusuru International in 2017, Z Capital expressed strong support for Modere’s growth trajectory and its “innovative Social Retail business model”.¹⁸ Despite Z Capital’s significant ownership stake, no public statements from the private equity firm regarding the reasons for or circumstances surrounding Modere’s April 2025 closure were identified in the reviewed materials. One unverified comment on a social media platform suggested the holding company initiated the shutdown without warning to Modere’s corporate administration.²¹

The period leading up to the closure was marked by significant leadership changes. Robert Conlee served as CEO during Z Capital’s earlier involvement and Modere’s acquisition phase.⁹ Asma Ishaq, co-founder of the acquired Jusuru, took over leadership in 2018 but subsequently departed the company.⁹ In late 2023, Nate Frazier was appointed President, Chief Operating Officer, and Executive Chairman.⁹ This appointment was followed by announcements of further strategic hires aimed at bolstering the leadership team and positioning the business for future growth in mid-2024.¹⁹

However, behind these public-facing moves, the company was grappling with significant internal conflict. In 2023, Modere terminated its top distributor, Justin Prince.⁹ The company subsequently filed a lawsuit against Prince, alleging that he had actively worked to “sabotage and crippled” the business.⁹ Reports indicate that this high-profile dispute was accompanied by the departure of other top distributors as well, suggesting potentially widespread dissatisfaction or instability within the company’s sales network.⁹ Modere had also faced other legal challenges involving distributors in prior years.²²

This internal turmoil creates a stark contrast with the company’s simultaneous positive announcements. Modere launched a new dietary supplement called “Curb” in late 2024, generating significant buzz.¹ It continued to receive industry recognition and awards ² and had recently discussed expansion plans.⁵ This juxtaposition of growth-oriented activities and accolades against a backdrop of leadership churn, legal battles with key distributors, and eventual sudden collapse makes the shutdown appear particularly “puzzling” to observers.⁵

The circumstances surrounding Modere’s demise under private equity ownership raise pertinent questions about the compatibility of typical PE strategies—often focused on maximizing short-to-medium term returns through potentially aggressive growth or restructuring—with the operational dynamics of an MLM business heavily reliant on distributor relationships, loyalty, and network stability. The abrupt nature of the closure, potentially directed by the holding company ²¹, could indicate a swift decision by Z Capital to cut losses when financial targets were missed or unforeseen liabilities emerged, possibly highlighting a clash between PE objectives and the inherent complexities of the MLM model.

Distributors in Disarray: The Human Cost of Closure

The immediate closure of Modere delivered a significant blow to its global network of independent distributors, often referred to as Social Marketers or brand ambassadors.⁸ These individuals relied on commissions generated from product sales and recruitment activities as a source of income, structured according to Modere’s compensation plan which rewarded customer acquisition and team building.¹

A primary source of frustration among distributors was the lack of advance warning. Several former affiliates reported receiving no prior notice, describing the handling of the closure as “very sudden and unprofessional”.⁸ This abruptness left distributors scrambling to understand the situation and respond to inquiries from their own customers.⁸ The company’s official statements thanking distributors for their dedication ³ rang hollow for many facing immediate financial uncertainty.

Specific concerns quickly centered on outstanding payments. Former affiliates expressed anxieties about unpaid commissions and the status of final payouts.⁸ Compounding these worries were reports of “abrupt changes in the brand’s affiliate portals”.⁸ These online portals are critical tools for distributors, providing access to sales data, commission statements, and downline network information. Sudden changes or restricted access would significantly hinder distributors’ ability to verify earnings or manage their business affairs during the critical shutdown period. While one resolved Better Business Bureau complaint from February 2025 (prior to the final closure) mentioned an internal charge for a “Social Marketer Fee” being deducted from future commissions, it highlights the fee structures distributors operated under.²⁶

In the aftermath, distributors were informed they might need to transition to other opportunities, with some reportedly exploring options with other MLM companies or establishing independent ventures.¹⁶ Industry news outlets expressed thoughts and prayers for the many families affected by the closure.²

The experience of Modere’s distributors underscores a fundamental vulnerability within the MLM business model. Individuals invest significant time, effort, and often personal funds to build their businesses under the umbrella of the parent company, yet they typically possess little control or transparency regarding corporate decisions, especially during times of financial distress or sudden closure. The reported lack of notice, unresolved payment issues, and system access problems severely damage the trust essential for the MLM structure and highlight the financial precarity faced by those whose livelihoods depend on it.

Customer Fallout: Orders, Refunds, and Frustration

Modere’s sudden closure reverberated throughout its customer base, triggering widespread shock, disappointment, and frustration, particularly among long-term loyal users.¹ Online platforms, including social media sites like X (formerly Twitter) and consumer complaint forums such as ComplaintsBoard and PissedConsumer, became outlets for customers voicing their dismay.⁸ Comments ranged from sadness over the loss of favored products—”So sad to hear Modere is closing. I’ve been using their products for years” and “Their products were a game-changer for me”—to urgent demands for resolution of outstanding issues.⁸

Specific complaints centered on logistical and financial problems arising directly from the shutdown. Numerous customers reported issues with pending or unshipped orders, leaving them uncertain about receiving products they had paid for.⁸ Even more prevalent were complaints regarding unresolved or significantly delayed refunds.⁸ One user on ComplaintsBoard explicitly asked, “I need my money back. How long do I need to wait?”.⁸

Compounding these problems was a perceived breakdown in customer service. Customers reported a lack of communication from the company and described the support experience during the closure period as “terrible,” citing delays and poor handling of inquiries.⁸ Reports of customer funds being “frozen” added to the sense of crisis.¹ At the time of initial reporting, Modere had not provided clear official guidance on how customers should handle ongoing orders, process returns, or claim pending refunds, further fueling disappointment and confusion.⁸ While previous contact information existed ²⁷ and the company had mechanisms for handling complaints ²⁶, these appeared overwhelmed or non-functional in the immediate aftermath of the closure announcement.

The widespread customer service failures during the shutdown risk significantly tarnishing Modere’s brand image and legacy. Despite operating for 23 years and cultivating a loyal following based on its “live clean” ethos, the chaotic and poorly communicated end-of-life process creates a lasting negative impression. This operational collapse during the critical closure phase potentially overshadows years of brand-building and customer loyalty, demonstrating how the manner of a company’s exit can profoundly impact its final perception.

Winding Down: Promises vs. Reality

In the wake of its closure announcement, Modere’s leadership communicated certain commitments regarding the wind-down process. Reports indicated the company pledged to fulfill all outstanding customer orders.³ Furthermore, Modere stated that customer service would remain available for a limited time specifically to handle refunds, exchanges, and other concerns related to the shutdown.³ It was also suggested that while existing stock might be available for a very short period, no new orders would be processed once current inventory was depleted.¹⁶

However, the reality reported by affected customers and distributors painted a starkly different picture. Instead of an orderly process, stakeholders described widespread confusion and a lack of clarity regarding procedures for resolving outstanding issues.⁸ Many reported significant delays or a complete lack of response when attempting to contact customer support.⁸ The immediate shutdown of the company website and the reported deactivation of social media accounts further hampered communication channels.¹ This left numerous customers and distributors feeling abandoned and “in the lurch”.⁸

Adding to the uncertainty was the company’s financial status. While Modere ceased operations globally due to severe business struggles, sources indicated that, at the time of reporting, the company had not officially filed for bankruptcy protection.¹⁶ An official bankruptcy filing would typically trigger established legal procedures for handling creditor claims, including those of customers and distributors, under court supervision. The absence of such a filing leaves the process for resolving outstanding financial obligations less clear.

The significant gap between Modere’s stated commitments for an orderly wind-down and the chaotic reality experienced by stakeholders points towards potential underlying issues. It could reflect a severe lack of financial or personnel resources necessary to manage the complexities of shutting down a global operation, particularly one precipitated by a sudden crisis. Alternatively, it might suggest a prioritization of obligations where available resources were directed towards secured creditors or other liabilities ahead of unsecured customer and distributor claims in an informal, out-of-court wind-down scenario. Regardless of the reason, the execution of the closure appeared to fall far short of the company’s public assurances.

Modere’s Profile: A ‘Live Clean’ Pioneer’s Journey

Founded in 2002 ⁵, Modere carved out a niche in the competitive health and wellness market by championing a “live clean” philosophy.¹² The company marketed itself as an omnichannel, consumer products company offering a portfolio of items purportedly free from controversial or potentially harmful ingredients, such as parabens.¹ Its product range spanned multiple categories, including health, wellness, beauty, personal care, and household essentials.¹ Products were reportedly manufactured in the United States in a facility certified by NSF for Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP).⁸

Modere utilized a multi-level marketing (MLM) structure, which it branded as “Social Retail”.¹ Under this model, independent distributors (Social Marketers) earned commissions by selling products directly to consumers and by recruiting new distributors into their network, earning additional overrides based on their downline’s sales volume.²⁵

Over its 23-year history, Modere achieved notable milestones and recognition. It expanded globally ²⁴, acquired companies like Jusuru International in 2017 to bolster its product line, particularly with collagen offerings ¹⁸, and launched new products like the Curb supplement in 2024.¹ Its Liquid BioCell Collagen product gained significant popularity and won industry awards.¹ The company also received accolades, such as being named the Fastest Growing Woman-Led Company by the Women Presidents Organization and JP Morgan Chase for multiple years ²³ and being listed among Newsweek’s Top 100 Most Loved Workplaces.²⁴

Table 1: Modere Key Events Timeline

Despite building its brand identity around concepts of “clean living,” transparency, and community well-being ³, Modere’s operational history reveals complexities. The company faced regulatory scrutiny from the DSSRC, prompted by TINA.org, over potentially unsubstantiated health claims and atypical income representations used in its marketing—claims that appear inconsistent with principles of transparency and accuracy.¹⁴ Furthermore, the manner of its closure—abrupt, opaque, and leaving many stakeholders feeling unsupported ¹—stands in contrast to its marketed image. This apparent paradox between the “clean living” branding and certain business practices raises questions about the alignment of marketing ideals with operational pressures and realities within the company.

Industry Headwinds and Regulatory Shadows

Modere’s closure did not occur in a vacuum. It reflects broader challenges confronting the multi-level marketing and direct selling industry, particularly in the post-pandemic era ¹,. Industry analysts point to several headwinds: market saturation, where the pool of potential recruits and customers becomes limited ⁸; intense competition not only from other MLMs but increasingly from mainstream e-commerce giants and nimble direct-to-consumer startups offering innovative products and competitive pricing ¹; and fundamental shifts in consumer behavior and preferences towards different purchasing models or product types ¹,. Several other established MLM companies have reportedly struggled, changed their compensation plans, or abandoned the MLM model altogether in recent years, including names like Color Street, Epicure, Rodan and Fields, Seint, BeachBody, and Tupperware.³⁰

The regulatory environment also appears to be a significant factor. Regulatory pressures and compliance costs were explicitly cited by sources close to Modere as contributing to its closure ¹,. The DSSRC’s 2023-2024 case decision against Modere, stemming from TINA.org’s investigation into unsubstantiated health and income claims, exemplifies this pressure.¹⁴ TINA.org has been actively monitoring and challenging marketing claims within the MLM industry, including specific campaigns related to menopause supplements, where Modere was also flagged.¹⁷ While the reviewed Federal Trade Commission (FTC) documents discuss general agency activities, refund statistics, fraud trends, and FOIA requests concerning other entities ³¹, they do not indicate a specific, public FTC investigation targeting Modere during the 2023-2025 period. However, the FTC remains active in policing deceptive practices, including those related to MLM income claims and health representations.²⁹

Expert commentary suggests that even well-established brands like Modere are vulnerable to these pressures.⁸ Survival in the current landscape requires innovation, agility, strong customer engagement, and potentially a move towards greater transparency regarding income potential.³ The contrast drawn between Modere’s closure and the continued operation of companies like Plexus Worldwide highlights the delicate balance required.³ Critics of the MLM model also point to inherent structural issues, such as the mathematics of endless recruitment chains leading inevitably to market saturation and losses for the vast majority of participants at the bottom of the pyramid.²⁹

The documented regulatory scrutiny faced by Modere over its marketing claims may have been more than just a background pressure; it could have acted as a direct catalyst or a significant contributing factor to its failure. Addressing the DSSRC’s findings likely necessitated costly changes to marketing strategies and distributor training, potentially hindering recruitment and sales momentum. The expense associated with ensuring compliance could have added substantial financial strain. Alternatively, the very need to make potentially exaggerated claims might have been a symptom of the underlying financial difficulties also cited as a reason for closure. This situation underscores the growing importance of regulatory compliance and ethical marketing practices for the long-term sustainability of MLM companies operating in an increasingly watchful environment.

Conclusion: Lingering Questions and Industry Implications

The sudden closure of Modere on April 11, 2025, marks the end of a 23-year chapter in the direct selling industry. The company, known for its “live clean” products and global MLM network, ceased operations abruptly, leaving behind a trail of unanswered questions and significant disruption for its distributors and customers worldwide. Despite expressions of gratitude in its final public statement, Modere offered no official explanation for the shutdown, fueling speculation about the underlying causes.

Key uncertainties remain. The precise combination of financial pressures, market shifts, internal conflicts, and regulatory burdens that led to the collapse is still unclear, obscured by the lack of corporate transparency. The company’s exact financial state, including whether it will pursue formal bankruptcy proceedings, was not confirmed at the time of reporting ¹⁶, leaving the process for resolving outstanding customer refunds and distributor commission claims ambiguous.

Modere’s departure creates a void in the clean-label wellness market it helped pioneer.⁸ For its many loyal customers and dedicated distributors, the closure represents not just the loss of products or income streams, but the dissolution of a community built over two decades.⁸

Beyond the immediate impact on its stakeholders, Modere’s collapse holds broader implications for the MLM/direct selling sector. It serves as a stark reminder of the industry’s vulnerability to evolving consumer behavior, intense competition from diverse retail channels, and the critical need for operational agility.³ The case highlights the potential instability introduced by factors such as private equity ownership focused on rapid returns, internal conflicts involving key network leaders, and the increasing weight of regulatory scrutiny over marketing claims.⁹ Ultimately, Modere’s story underscores the imperative for MLM companies to prioritize transparency, ensure robust compliance, effectively manage internal and external pressures, and adapt proactively to a rapidly changing market landscape if they are to achieve sustainable long-term success.³

References

• ¹ Inside Modere as source details the reasons behind shock closure of once-bestselling business – The Mirror US. (themirror.com)
• ⁵ Top health & beauty company shuts down after over two decades, leaving millions of customers shocked. (mundodeportivo.com)
• ⁸ Modere Closes After 23 Years of Service. (colitco.com)
• ⁹ Modere Is Closing: Here’s What We Know About It Shutting Down – Blavity. (blavity.com)
• ⁶ Modere Announces Closure After 23 Years – Direct Selling News. (directsellingnews.com)
• ² Modere Announces Immediate Closure After 23 Years – Direct Selling Facts, Figures and News. (businessforhome.org)
• ¹³ Why are Modere customers disappointed, and what was the brand known for? (hindustantimes.com)
• ¹² Modere Closes After 23 Years, Thanks Loyal Customers. (stories.jobaaj.com)
• ³ Modere Shuts Down. (tnj.com)
• ¹⁶ Modere Shuts Down After 23 Years – Here’s What Happened! (stories.jobaaj.com)
• ⁷ Inside Modere as source details the reasons behind shock closure of once-bestselling business – The Mirror US. (themirror.com)
• ¹¹ Modere Announces Closure After 23 Years – Direct Selling Facts, Figures and News. (businessforhome.org)
• ³⁰ The Future of Network Marketing and New Threats in 2025. (mlmnation.com)
• ¹⁰ Modere Announces Closure After 23 Years: End of an Era in Direct Selling. (gactvm.in)
• ³⁶ Modere CEO Asma Ishaq Named in Forbes as Top Transformational CEO in Health & Beauty Ecommerce. (prweb.com)
• ¹⁸ Modere Announces Agreement to Acquire Jusuru International. (prnewswire.com)
• ²³ Modere Recognized as Fastest Growing Woman-Led Company by The Women Presidents Organization and JP Morgan Chase. (prnewswire.com)
• ²² CaseMine Search Results for “jessie lee ward modere”. (casemine.com)
• ²⁸ Celebrity Nutritionist Robert Ferguson Joins Modere Scientific Advisory Board. (prweb.com)
• ³⁷ Credit Mutuel Arkea Consolidated Financial Statements – 31 December 2020. (cm-arkea.com)
• ³⁸ World Bank Document – Lebanon Country Partnership Framework FY16-FY22. (documents1.worldbank.org)
• ³⁹ PhD Thesis – Public Private Partnership Models for Urban Regeneration Projects. (research-collection.ethz.ch)
• ⁴⁰ Society in Crisis: France in the Sixteenth Century. (publishing.cdlib.org)
• ¹⁵ Modere Collapses After 23 Years: What Went Wrong? (stories.jobaaj.com)
• ²⁴ MODERE Tag – Direct Selling News. (directsellingnews.com)
• ⁴¹ Home – Direct Selling News. (directsellingnews.com)
• ⁴ Case #144-2023: NGO Inquiry – Modere USA, Inc. (bbbprograms.org)
• ³⁴ Defining Direct Selling. (directsellingnews.com)
• ²¹ Reddit Discussion on Modere Closure. (reddit.com)
• ³ Modere Shuts Down. (tnj.com)
• ⁶ Modere Announces Closure After 23 Years – Direct Selling News. (directsellingnews.com)
• ⁴² SEC Filing – Warrant Information. (sec.gov)
• ⁴³ SEC Filing – Z Capital Affinity Merger Agreement. (sec.gov)
• ¹⁸ Modere Announces Agreement to Acquire Jusuru International. (prnewswire.com)
• ²⁰ Z Capital Partners Becomes Majority Controlling Shareholder of Neways. (prnewswire.com)
• ¹⁹ Mōdere Appoints Nate Frazier as President, Chief Operating Officer and Executive Chairman. (businesswire.com)
• ⁸ Modere Closes After 23 Years of Service. (colitco.com)
• ¹ Inside Modere as source details the reasons behind shock closure of once-bestselling business – The Mirror US. (themirror.com)
• ¹⁶ Modere Shuts Down After 23 Years – Here’s What Happened! (stories.jobaaj.com)
• ¹¹ Modere Announces Closure After 23 Years – Direct Selling Facts, Figures and News. (businessforhome.org)
• ⁹ Modere Is Closing: Here’s What We Know About It Shutting Down – Blavity. (blavity.com)
• ² Modere Announces Immediate Closure After 23 Years – Direct Selling Facts, Figures and News. (businessforhome.org)
• ²⁵ Modere Compensation Plan PDF. (static1.squarespace.com)
• ⁷ Inside Modere as source details the reasons behind shock closure of once-bestselling business – The Mirror US. (themirror.com)
• ¹² Modere Closes After 23 Years, Thanks Loyal Customers. (stories.jobaaj.com)
• ¹⁴ Modere’s 23-Year Reign Comes to a Dramatic End – What Went Wrong? (nataregistration.in)
• ¹³ Why are Modere customers disappointed, and what was the brand known for? (hindustantimes.com)
• ²⁷ Modere FAQ Page (Archival/Pre-Closure). (modere.com)
• ²⁶ BBB Complaints for Modere Inc. (bbb.org)
• ⁴⁴ MODEC, INC. Financial Results (Not Modere). (modec.com)
• ⁴⁵ Alstom Half Year Results Management Report 2023/24 (Not Modere). (alstom.com)
• ⁴⁶ Alstom Half Year Financial Report 2023/24 (Not Modere). (ml-eu.globenewswire.com)
• ⁴⁷ Alstom Half Year Financial Report 2024/25 (Not Modere). (alstom.com)
• ⁴⁸ Coface Universal Registration Document 2023 (Not Modere). (coface.com)
• ⁴⁹ World Bank Project Document Snippet (Not Modere). (documents1.worldbank.org)
• ³¹ New Report Shows FTC Returned $337.3 Million to Consumers in 2024. (ftc.gov)
• ³³ New FTC Data Show a Big Jump in Reported Losses to Fraud to $12.5 Billion in 2024. (ftc.gov)
• ⁵⁰ FTC Open FOIA Report January 2025 (Excel Snippet). (ftc.gov)
• ⁵¹ FTC: Consumers Lost $12.5 Billion to Investment, Other Scammers in 2024. (insurancejournal.com)
• ⁵² FTC Updates: December 16 – December 27, 2024. (retailconsumerproductslaw.com)
• ³² FTC Open FOIA Report December 2024 (Excel Snippet). (ftc.gov)
• ¹⁷ Truth in Advertising (TINA.org) Brand Page for Modere. (truthinadvertising.org)
• ³ Modere Shuts Down. (tnj.com)
• ¹ Inside Modere as source details the reasons behind shock closure of once-bestselling business – The Mirror US. (themirror.com)
• ⁵ Top health & beauty company shuts down after over two decades, leaving millions of customers shocked. (mundodeportivo.com)
• ⁹ Modere Is Closing: Here’s What We Know About It Shutting Down – Blavity. (blavity.com)
• ⁶ Modere Announces Closure After 23 Years – Direct Selling News. (directsellingnews.com)
• ²⁹ The Case (for and) against Multi-level Marketing by Jon M. Taylor (FTC Public Comment). (ftc.gov)
• ³⁵ Multilevel Marketing Diffusion and the Risk of Pyramid Scheme Activity (ResearchGate Publication Snippet). (researchgate.net)
• ¹ Analysis of The Mirror US article on Modere closure reasons and wind-down. (Internal Analysis)
• ⁹ Analysis of Blavity article on Z Capital, internal issues, and leadership changes. (Internal Analysis)
• ⁸ Analysis of Colitco article on distributor/customer impact (commissions, portals, refunds). (Internal Analysis)
• ¹⁶ Analysis of Jobaaj Stories article on wind-down, refunds, distributors, reasons. (Internal Analysis)
• ³ Analysis of TNJ article on financial struggles, market shifts, regulatory pressure, closure handling. (Internal Analysis)
• ⁶ Analysis of Direct Selling News article confirming details beyond initial announcement. (Internal Analysis)

Works cited

1. Inside Modere as source details the reasons behind shock closure of once-bestselling business – The Mirror US, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.themirror.com/money/inside-modere-source-details-reasons-1089432
2. Modere Announces Immediate Closure After 23 Years – Direct Selling Facts, Figures and News – Business For Home, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.businessforhome.org/2025/04/modere-announces-immediately-closure-after-23-years/
3. Modere Shuts Down After 23 Years: What Really Happened? – The Network Journal, accessed April 13, 2025, https://tnj.com/modere-shuts-down/
4. Case #144-2023: NGO Inquiry – Modere USA, Inc. – BBB National Programs, accessed April 13, 2025, https://bbbprograms.org/programs/advertising/dssrc/cases/dssrc-modereusa
5. Top health & beauty company shuts down after over two decades, leaving millions of customers shocked – Mundo Deportivo, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.mundodeportivo.com/us/en/20250412/720283/top-health-beauty-company-shuts-down-after-over-two-decades-leaving-millions-of-customers-shocked.html
6. Modere Announces Closure After 23 Years – Direct Selling News, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.directsellingnews.com/2025/04/11/modere-announces-closure-after-23-years/
7. Inside Modere as source details the reasons behind shock closure of once-bestselling business – The Mirror US, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.themirror.com/money/inside-modere-closing-down-once-1089432
8. Modere Closes After 23 Years – Colitco, accessed April 13, 2025, https://colitco.com/modere-closes-after-23-years-of-service/
9. Modere Is Closing: Here’s What We Know About It Shutting Down – Blavity, accessed April 13, 2025, https://blavity.com/modere-is-closing
10. GACTVM – Global News, accessed April 13, 2025, http://gactvm.in/
11. Modere Announces Closure After 23 Years – Direct Selling Facts, Figures and News, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.businessforhome.org/2025/04/modere-announces-closure-after-23-years/
12. Modere Closes After 23 Years, Thanks Loyal Customers – Jobaaj Stories, accessed April 13, 2025, https://stories.jobaaj.com/news-updates/lifestyle/modere-closes-after-23-years-thanks-loyal-customers
13. Why are Modere customers disappointed, and what was the brand known for? – Hindustan Times, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.hindustantimes.com/world-news/us-news/why-are-modere-customers-disappointed-and-what-was-the-brand-known-for-101744445292790.html
14. Modere’s 23-Year Reign Comes to a Dramatic End – What Went Wrong? – Nata registration, accessed April 13, 2025, https://nataregistration.in/moderes-23-year-reign-comes-to-a-dramatic-end/
15. Modere Collapses After 23 Years: What Went Wrong? – Jobaaj Stories, accessed April 13, 2025, https://stories.jobaaj.com/news-updates/lifestyle/modere-collapses-after-23-years-what-went-wrong
16. Modere Shuts Down After 23 Years – Here’s What Happened!, accessed April 13, 2025, https://stories.jobaaj.com/news-updates/business/modere-shuts-down-after-23-years-here-s-what-happened
17. Modere – Truth in Advertising – TINA.org, accessed April 13, 2025, https://truthinadvertising.org/brands/modere/
18. Modere Announces Agreement to Acquire Jusuru International – PR Newswire, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/modere-announces-agreement-to-acquire-jusuru-international-300392723.html
19. Mōdere Appoints Nate Frazier as President, Chief Operating Officer, and Executive Chairman | Business Wire, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20231217713671/en/M%C5%8Ddere-Appoints-Nate-Frazier-as-President-Chief-Operating-Officer-and-Executive-Chairman
20. Z Capital Partners Becomes Majority Controlling Shareholder of Neways, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/z-capital-partners-becomes-majority-controlling-shareholder-of-neways-215187741.html
21. Modere 23 years and closed its doors.. : r/antiMLM – Reddit, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/antiMLM/comments/1jx1382/modere_23_years_and_closed_its_doors/
22. jessie+lee+ward+modere | US Decisions | Law – CaseMine, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.casemine.com/search/us/jessie%2Blee%2Bward%2Bmodere
23. Modere Recognized as Fastest Growing Woman-Led Company by the Women Presidents’ Organization and JP Morgan Chase – PR Newswire, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/modere-recognized-as-fastest-growing-woman-led-company-by-the-women-presidents-organization-and-jp-morgan-chase-301393175.html
24. MODERE – Direct Selling News, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.directsellingnews.com/tag/modere/
25. Modere Compensation Plan PDF – Squarespace, accessed April 13, 2025, https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5388101ae4b04631a5e04b76/t/5de50742e6b0e7013ac45e15/1575290692217/Modere-Compensation-Plan.pdf
26. Modere, Inc. | BBB Complaints | Better Business Bureau, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.bbb.org/us/ut/springville/profile/health-products/modere-inc-1166-86090006/complaints
27. Modere FAQs | Return Policy, Shipping and More, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.modere.com/en-US/faq
28. Celebrity Nutritionist Robert Ferguson Joins Modere Scientific Advisory Board – PRWeb, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.prweb.com/releases/celebrity-nutritionist-robert-ferguson-joins-modere-scientific-advisory-board-801663746.html
29. MARKET SATURATION AND COLLAPSE – how established MLMs skirt two major flaws in their systems Chapter contents – Federal Trade Commission, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/public_comments/trade-regulation-rule-disclosure-requirements-and-prohibitions-concerning-business-opportunities-ftc.r511993-00009%C2%A0/00009-57282.pdf
30. The Future of Network Marketing and New Threats in 2025 – MLM Nation, accessed April 13, 2025, https://mlmnation.com/future-of-network-marketing-841/
31. New Report Shows FTC Returned $337.3 Million to Consumers in 2024, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2025/03/new-report-shows-ftc-returned-3373-million-consumers-2024
32. Sheet1 – Federal Trade Commission, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/documents/december-open-foia-requests-report.xlsx
33. New FTC Data Show a Big Jump in Reported Losses to Fraud to $12.5 Billion in 2024, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2025/03/new-ftc-data-show-big-jump-reported-losses-fraud-125-billion-2024
34. Defining Direct Selling, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.directsellingnews.com/2024/09/01/defining-direct-selling/
35. Multilevel Marketing Diffusion and the Risk of Pyramid Scheme Activity: The Case of Fortune Hi-Tech Marketing in Montana | Request PDF – ResearchGate, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/273313889_Multilevel_Marketing_Diffusion_and_the_Risk_of_Pyramid_Scheme_Activity_The_Case_of_Fortune_Hi-Tech_Marketing_in_Montana
36. Modere CEO Asma Ishaq Named in Forbes as Top Transformational CEO in Health & Beauty: Ecommerce – PRWeb, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.prweb.com/releases/modere-ceo-asma-ishaq-named-in-forbes-as-top-transformational-ceo-in-health-amp-beauty-ecommerce-824293228.html
37. Consolidated financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2020 Non audited consolidated financial statements – Crédit Mutuel Arkéa, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.cm-arkea.com/arkea/banque/assurances/c_6827/en/31-december-2020
38. lebanon: promoting poverty reduction and shared prosperity – World Bank Documents and Reports, accessed April 13, 2025, https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/698161468179049613/pdf/97498-cas-p151430-secm2015-0202-ifc-secm2015-0073-miga-secm2015-0047-box391476b-ouo-9.pdf
39. Performance Review of Public-Private Partnerships and their Application Potential in Housing – Research Collection, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.research-collection.ethz.ch/bitstream/handle/20.500.11850/259978/3/PhDThesis-RITIKABATRA.pdf
40. One King, One Faith – UC Press E-Books Collection, accessed April 13, 2025, https://publishing.cdlib.org/ucpressebooks/view?docId=ft409nb2zv;chunk.id=0;doc.view=print
41. Direct Selling News: Home, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.directsellingnews.com/
42. 424B4 – SEC.gov, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1806156/000119312521028928/d40658d424b4.htm
43. schedule 14a – SEC.gov, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1499268/000104746916016100/a2229656zprem14a.htm
44. 2024 Full-Year Financial Results – MODEC, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.modec.com/ir/library/result/assets/pdf/2024_YE_results_en.pdf
45. Financial report Half-year – Alstom, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.alstom.com/sites/alstom.com/files/2023/11/14/20231115_Half_Year_Results_Management_Report_EN.pdf
46. Financial report Half-year – Notified, accessed April 13, 2025, https://ml-eu.globenewswire.com/Resource/Download/86a4e5a0-22b8-4476-bea9-39bb9749d48f
47. Financial report Half-year – Alstom, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.alstom.com/sites/alstom.com/files/2024/11/18/20241118_Half_Year_Financial_Report_EN.pdf
48. UNIVERSAL REGISTRATION DOCUMENT 2023 – Coface, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.coface.com/content/download/53484/file/2024%2004%2005%20COFACE%20URD%202023%20UK%20Web.pdf
49. P17301803e30a40a008bb20a7… – World Bank Documents and Reports, accessed April 13, 2025, https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099062923180511368/text/P17301803e30a40a008bb20a7480c6ba607.txt
50. Sheet1 – Federal Trade Commission, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/documents/January%202025%20Open%20FOIA%20Report.xlsx
51. FTC: Consumers Lost $12.5 Billion to Investment, Other Scammers in 2024, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/national/2025/03/10/815001.htm
52. FTC Updates (December 16 – December 27, 2024) | Retail & Consumer Products Law Observer, accessed April 13, 2025, https://www.retailconsumerproductslaw.com/2025/01/ftc-updates-december-16-december-27-2024/